The absolute best vegan peanut butter fudge brownie milkshake uses leftover brownies to make the most amazing vegan chocolate milkshake ever.
Want to Save This Recipe?
Enter your email & we'll send it to your inbox. Plus you’ll get great new recipes from us every week.
There is not a better combination that peanut butter and chocolate. Okay, there may be a few that can compete, but if you love this combo, then you are in for a treat with this vegan peanut butter fudge brownie milkshake (pun intended).
We are combining delicious vegan ice cream with leftover brownies and goobs of peanut butter to make one incredible delicious vegan milkshake.
The end result is one epic vegan milkshake idea that will blow you away.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I make this Top 8 Allergen Free?
Yes! Make sure that you choose a vegan ice cream and plant based milk that is safe for your allergens.
If needed you could make your own Top 8 Allergen free vegan vanilla ice cream by following the tips for making it so in our post.
As for the graham crackers and birthday cake, technically you could omit these or you can create gluten free versions. Try using gluten free flour for our vegan graham crackers and vegan vanilla cake (just add vegan sprinkles).
Lastly, follow our instructions for allergen friendly vegan brownies if you need to make those first.
Can I prep these ahead?
We don’t recommend that you try to make these ahead.
If you are making from scratch and not using leftover brownies, then you could definitely make the brownies before hand; however, the actually milkshake is best made when ready to eat.
What is the best vegan chocolate for melting?
We really love Enjoy Life for melting. It’s allergen friendly and it melts really easily.
What the best type of milk for a vegan milkshake?
A very neutral plant based milk is best for milkshakes so that the milk itself doesn’t impart too much flavor into your milkshake.
For that, we prefer a milk like oat milk, but any neutral plant based milk will work.
How do I make my vegan milkshake thicker if I added too much vegan milk accidentally?
This happens (even to us). Sometimes our “splash” of milk actually comes out much faster than we anticipate. Oops!
No worries, you can either add ice to make it thicker.
Or also since this is a brownie milkshake, adding more brownies could also aiding in the thickening process.
I don’t have brownies can I omit?
Yes you can! It would just be a peanut butter milkshake then, but it’s not a requirement if you don’t have any.
Do I have to do the fancy rim?
Of course not. It’s just fancy and while it’s edible, it’s not needed.
Can I double the milkshake all at once or do I need to make one by one?
If you need to make more than one milkshake, then you can absolutely do it all at one time.
Just add the same amount of ingredients for how many you need. Make sure you don’t go over your blenders max line.
Pin this vegan peanut butter fudge brownie milkshake for later:
🥳 Get the Full Recipe
Vegan Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie Milkshake
Ingredients
- 3 scoops vegan vanilla ice cream
- 1-2 tablespoon neutral plant based milk (we like oat)
- 1 handful leftover brownies (roughly ½ to ¾ cup)
- 2 heaping spoonfuls peanut butter
Garnish
- vegan whipped cream
- 2 tablespoon melted vegan chocolate
- 1 brownie
Instructions
- *The idea behind this is that you are using leftover brownies and other store bought ingredients to make this go faster; however if needed you can DIY the entire thing (it will just take longer than 5 minutes). Use these homemade recipes (click on links):*Vegan Vanilla Ice Cream *Vegan Brownies*Vegan Whipped Topping
- Drizzle melted chocolate along the rim of the glass. Set aside.
- Add vegan ice cream, dairy free milk, brownie, and peanut butter into a blender. Blend until combined.
- Add milkshake into the cup.
- Add a brownie to the side of the glass. Top with vegan whip cream.
- Enjoy!
Oh my gosh loved it !!! I made the brownies and I cried they remind me of dairy brownies . I’m so appreciative of this recipe so I can have my favorites as a vegan !!
We’re so happy to hear you are liking the recipe. Thanks for taking time to leave a review. Have a great week.